I am one of DC’s target customers, a new reader brought in at the prospect of new #1s, and new storylines. I like the idea of being able to wade in without having to sift through years of backstories and things I know nothing about, or jumping in at the mid-point of a story arc, and thus find myself doubly lost. So, it’s with a lot of excitement I got my nerd on and started following some of my favorite heroes, and branching off into new stuff, too. What follows are my thoughts on the first 2-3 issues of several series.
I’m also going to include a “Reboot Factor” from 1-10. A rating of 10 means I consider this a total reboot, that those without extensive comic knowledge (like me) could pick up and get into without feeling lost. A 1 means I don’t feel it’s much of a reboot at all, and those unfamiliar with the characters or universe are likely to be a somewhat lost. At the end, I’ll rank them all in order of favorites, so far.
Justice League (Issues 1-3)
Of course I’m going to pick up Justice League, which is DC’s flagship series. Having Batman in it helps, but I’d have read it even without Bruce Wayne. Some mysterious alien artifacts are turning up around the world, leading to explosions and lots of demons appearing to abduct people, for reasons currently unknown. Issue 1 featured Batman, Green Lantern, and Superman. Issue 2 added Flash, Issue 3 adds Wonder Woman, and Issue 4 is set to introduce Aqua Man. Cyborg’s backstory has been a factor of Issues 1-3, though he has not interacted with the other heroes.
With the number of heroes in the comic, things are naturally going to take some time to set up, so I’m not too concerned that there’s not a lot of traction in the story through three issues. The art is pretty good, and writer Geoff Johns has a knack for snappy dialogue, that helps keep things moving and interesting.
REBOOT FACTOR: 9
These heroes are meeting each other for the first time, and several of them didn’t believe the others actually existed. Metahumans (aka people with super powers) are a new thing in the global landscape. Most necessary information on the characters is related to the reader through dialogue. Familiarity with the characters probably helps, but I didn’t feel hindered during issue 3 because I don’t know much about Wonder Woman.
Teen Titans (Issues 1-2)
I’m familiar with Teen Titans as I used to watch the cartoon on Cartoon Network. These aren’t the same Teen Titans at all. The character roster is completely different, and with only two issues out, it’s hard to tell if they’ll play similar roles to the old crew. Through 2 issues, we’re starting to see the formation of the crew, like with Justice League. I like Red Robin, but Cassie Sandsmark (aka Wonder Girl) kind of annoys me. I miss the old Starfire, who was so totally an anime character trapped in an american cartoon, and I loved her for it. The other characters have not had enough pages to make an impression. The basic premise is Teen Titans vs. a government agency kidnapping metahumans.
REBOOT FACTOR: 9
It’s a totally new cast, with their back stories being built up as we go. Knowledge of Red Robin may help you, but a lack of it does not really matter.
Green Lantern (Issues 1-3)
Hal Jordan isn’t a Green Lantern anymore. Sinestro has his ring back, after losing it for being a total douche (over-simplification on my part). Sinestro recruits Hal to help him reclaim his homeworld, which is now enslaved by the Yellow Lanterns he created.
REBOOT FACTOR: 2
We’re a long way from retreading origin stories here. Sinestro makes comments that Hal has blown it with the Green Lantern Corps multiple times already. Hal has a history with a woman I know nothing about. This may be a new storyline, but it hardly feels at all like a reboot, as there’s a lot of references in the first three issues I just don’t follow. The art looks good, and the ending to #3 is a hell of a cliffhanger, but I’m not blown away by the series so far.
Green Lantern Corps (Issues 1-3)
Some alien force is royally fucking up the Lanterns. It’s capable of destroying worlds. That’s all I know after three issues, as each issue shows the Lanterns getting the crap kicked out of them. OK, it’s high stakes. Big Powerful Bad Guy. I get it. It’s hard to invest in the characters when I have no idea which ones are going to be alive or dead in the next issue. This appears so far to be a more situation-driven than character-driven series.
REBOOT FACTOR: 3
It’s slightly more forgiving as more time is spent on the human characters in #1, but the bodies keep piling up with little time wasted on exposition.
Batman (Issues 2-3)
I haven’t been able to track down Batman #1 yet, so I’ve just carried on with 2-3. Batman has to content with the Court of Owls, a shadow organization said to be secretly ruling Gotham since colonial times.
REBOOT FACTOR: 6
It’s hard to say for sure without reading #1, but this feels pretty fresh. Nightwing makes a cameo without much fanfare, suggesting this is farther along in Batman’s life. Some time is spent mentioning Batman lost his parents, but most back-story is out. With the world’s most famous hero though, do you really need that? I believe the Court of Owls is a new enemy, and I enjoy that fresh start, rather than immediately squaring off with known foes like Joker or Two-Face. Batman has the best writing of the Batman comic lines, though strangely has the least appealing art.
Batman – Detective Comics (Issues 2-3)
Again, I’m late to the party to find a #1. This series plays up Batman’s detective skills more than the other series do. In this line, Batman has to take on the Dollmaker, an enemy with ties to Gordon’s Past.
REBOOT FACTOR: 6
New enemy, same old Batman. What else is there to say?
Batman and Robin (Issues 1-3)
Damien, Batman’s son, takes on the role of Robin in this series, which seems to focus strongly on the relationship between the two title characters. Damien has a violent nature, and it’s up to Batman to raise him right, while a newcomer tried to corrupt him.
REBOOT FACTOR: 3
It’s an uphill battle if you don’t know where Damien comes from (I don’t), or who Talia is. She’s the boy’s mother, but I know nothing of her history with Batman, or the kid’s early years. I like the character dynamics, though I know little of this Robin.
Batman – The Dark Knight (Issues 1-2)
This incarnation is by far the most violent and bloody of the Batman line. Some drug has Two-Face and Joker looking like steroid abusing hulks. I’m a little put off by most of the characters looking like they should be in Gears of War, not a Batman comic.
REBOOT FACTOR: 3
It’s assumed you know about Arkham Asylum, Two-Face, Joker, etc.
Catwoman (Issues 1-3)
Catwoman is the most M-rated of the DC comics I’m following. Lots of sex, blood, and tits. I know Catwoman is a rogue and a thief, but her character here isn’t very likable, and I don’t much care for Batman’s character in this series. So far, issues 1-3 have focused on the theft of a painting and the resulting trouble with the Russian mob. If I chose to drop a subscription, this will be the first to go.
REBOOT FACTOR: 7
Her background is explained a little, but anyone reading this series is likely to be familiar with her anyway.
Nightwing (Issues 1-3)
Nightwing is Dick Grayson, the first Robin, all grown up and gone solo. A professional killer has been hired to take him out, for reasons he does not know. I like the characters of Nightwing, and the story’s progression so far. Each issue adds to the picture while making it more complicated. Unlike Green Lantern Corps, I see forward momentum with this series.
REBOOT FACTOR: 9
The first three issues are revolve around the circus where Dick grew up as a boy, and his current interactions with the people there, his former family. His connections to Batman are made clear early on, and there’s a lot of exploration for who Dick is, making this series very new-reader friendly.
Supergirl (Issues 1-3)
I’ve never been a Superman fan, but I find Supergirl’s character more interesting. She lands on Earth knowing of her past on Krypton, but not of Earth or her new powers. In issues 1-3, she’s in denial that she’s really on Earth, and has no idea how to control her power. To make matters worse, a powerful agency has stolen the pod she arrived in, and now intends to experiment on her, as well.
REBOOT FACTOR: 10
The series literally begins with Kara crashing down to Earth. If that’s not starting from the beginning, I don’t know what is. Some knowledge of Superman and the fate of Krypton may help, but this is the most new-reader friendly of any of the DC comics I’ve read.
So, those were some brief thoughts on the comics I’ve been following. Don’t want to read all of those? Have time for only the best? Here’s how I would rank them on my favorites, from best to worst, so far:
- Nightwing
- Batman
- Justice League
- Batman – Detective Comics
- Supergirl
- Batman and Robin
- Teen Titans
- Green Lantern
- Batman – The Dark Knight
- Green Lantern Corps
- Catwoman